Theatre Workshop of Nantucket (TWN) is delighted to welcome Broadway star Andrea McArdle and television and stage favorite Robert Newman to Bennett Hall for its highly anticipated holiday production of Elin Hilderbrand’s Winter Street, on stage from November 24 through December 6. McArdle will portray Margaret Quinn, opposite Newman, who returns for his third season as Kelly Quinn, in the heartwarming and hilarious holiday story inspired by the bestselling novels of Nantucket’s own Elin Hilderbrand.
In its third holiday season, Winter Street has quickly become a cherished Nantucket tradition. Adapted for the stage and directed by TWN Artistic Director Justin Cerne, the production brings Hilderbrand’s beloved Quinn family to life in a story filled with love, laughter, family secrets, unexpected reunions, and the beautiful chaos of the holiday season. Set against the familiar backdrop of Nantucket at Christmastime, Winter Street captures both the magic of the island and the complicated, often hilarious relationships that make families unforgettable.
“There’s something really special about bringing Winter Street back to the stage,” said Artistic Director Justin Cerne. “It’s a story that feels so distinctly Nantucket, and audiences have really embraced it as part of their holiday traditions. We’re thrilled to welcome Andrea McArdle to the Quinn family this year. She’s an extraordinary performer, and pairing her with Robert Newman, who has made the role of Kelly his own over the past three seasons, is going to be a real treat. Robert brings such warmth, humor, and heart to this character, and I can’t wait to see the chemistry between these two wonderful actors. It’s the perfect way to wrap up our 70th anniversary season.”
Andrea McArdle first captured the hearts of audiences around the world when she originated the title role in Broadway’s Annie in 1977. Her performance earned her a Tony Award nomination for Best Actress in a Musical, making her the youngest performer ever nominated in that category at the time. She also received Theatre World and Outer Critics’ Circle Awards for her performance. McArdle went on to enjoy an extraordinary Broadway career, appearing in Les Misérables as Fantine, Beauty and the Beast as Belle, Starlight Express, State Fair, and Jerry’s Girls. An acclaimed concert performer, she has appeared at Carnegie Hall, the White House, and concert venues worldwide. In Winter Street, McArdle plays Margaret Quinn, the glamorous and complicated matriarch whose unexpected return to Nantucket sets the stage for a memorable family holiday.
Robert Newman returns to the role of Kelly Quinn for the third time, having originated the character in Theatre Workshop’s 2024 world premiere production and reprised the role in 2025. Newman has become a familiar and much-loved presence in this holiday production, bringing his charm, comedic timing, and emotional depth to the role of the Winter Street Inn’s beleaguered patriarch.
Newman is best known to tv audiences for his celebrated 28-year portrayal of Joshua Lewis on the long-running CBS daytime drama Guiding Light, a role that earned him two Daytime Emmy Award nominations for Outstanding Lead Actor. His extensive television credits also include Homeland, Chicago Fire, Criminal Minds, NCIS, and Law & Order: SVU. Equally accomplished on stage, Newman has appeared in numerous regional and Off-Broadway productions, including Man of La Mancha, Gypsy, Fiddler on the Roof, Deathtrap, and The Lion in Winter.
Originally published in 2014, Hilderbrand’s Winter Street launched a beloved four-book series chronicling the lives, loves, and holiday adventures of the Quinn family. Cerne’s stage adaptation draws from the series to create an entertaining and deeply moving theatrical experience that celebrates family, forgiveness, and the enduring spirit of Nantucket.
“My novel Winter Street debuted in 2014, and the series gained readers with the three books that followed. Justin Cerne has brilliantly and seamlessly blended the books into a charming, funny, heartwarming play that is just perfect for Nantucket at the holidays. I’m thrilled that the Quinn family is having their moment on the stage,” said Hilderbrand.
In addition to Winter Street, TWN invites audiences to celebrate Thanksgiving weekend with A Broadway White Christmas at 7 pm November 27 or at 5 pm November 28.
This festive installment of its On With The Show cabaret series features Adam Roberts, Alysha Umphress, Farah Alvin, Paul Canaan, and Jacob Yandura in a holiday cabaret that brings together an accomplished company of Broadway performers and artists for an intimate celebration of Broadway hits and seasonal favorites.
Whether gathering with family, welcoming friends home, or beginning a favorite holiday tradition, audiences can enjoy the warmth and excitement of live performance over Thanksgiving weekend at A Broadway White Christmas. Ticket to this cabaret are available at theatrenantucket.com
The return of Winter Street provides a festive conclusion to Theatre Workshop of Nantucket’s landmark 70th anniversary season, celebrating seven decades of bringing professional live theatre to the island. From Broadway favorites to new works and locally inspired productions, TWN continues its tradition of bringing exceptional theatrical experiences to the Nantucket community.
Performances of Elin Hilderbrand’s Winter Street (November 24-December 6) are generally at 7 pm, with Sunday performances at 5 pm. Additional matinees are scheduled for December 4 at 2 pm and December 5 at 1 pm. Tickets are available at theatrenantucket.org