by Suzanne Daub
Shortly before 10 am every Thanksgiving morning, while many Americans are seasoning turkeys and scouting for the good tablecloth, more than a thousand people on Nantucket Island are standing shoulder to shoulder on Children’s Beach, shivering in swimsuits and grinning, waiting for the countdown to sprint into the harbor. This year, the island Thanksgiving tradition called the Nantucket Atheneum’s Cold Turkey Plunge turns 25.
The idea for this important fundraiser was brought to our island by local resident Barbara Clarke from her home town in Skerries, north of Dublin, where a Christmas Day swim is a lively annual event. “I did that from the age of 4 or 5: it was a huge part of Christmas Day there,” she recalled. “We would go to church, swim, visit friends, then go home to eat turkey.”
Years later, when Atheneum Board Member Nancy Newhouse and Adrienne McCalley were seeking ideas on how to raise funds for the Weezie Children’s Library, Clarke reached out to them to describe her home town’s tradition. Newhouse and McCalley thought it was a great idea to bring to Nantucket.
“I explained how the whole town in Ireland embraced it,” said Clarke, “and now it is very heartwarming to see how Nantucketers have embraced it.”
Newhouse brought the idea to the next board meeting and recalls the members as initially being somewhat skeptical, but after she described the concept more fully to each board member, at the next meeting the idea was enthusiastically adopted.
Even a good idea needs dedicated people to implement and execute it. “Our first organizing committee was great,” said Clarke. Many of the original organizing committee members—Bess Clarke, Lucy Hehir, Gabrielle Gould, Kady Decker, Eleanor Antonette, Tom Hanlon, Logan O’Connor, Eleanor Antonette, Barbara Clarke, Adrienne McCalley, and Nancy Newhouse—worked together on the Plunge for more than a decade. It was Bess Clarke who came up with the original catchy tagline of “Freezin for a Reason,” that is still used today. “We had so much creative license with this event” said Bess.
The first year, 195 people took the plunge and raised $32,000. “We thought that was a great success,” commented Bess Clarke. “Twenty-five years ago,” she reminisced, “there was nothing to do out here for Thanksgiving. [The Cold Turkey Plunge] gave people a reason to come out and gave them a sense of accomplishment and camaraderie…Now people come for it: hotels stay open and cater to the people who plunge.” Plus, she added, the Plunge “is the most brilliant model for fundraising—it checks all the boxes: it’s fun, there’s low overhead, it’s not expensive to participate, there’s team building, you’re out in Nature…It’s quick: we set up at 7 am, the event is at 10 am, and by 11 am we’re all home. And cleanup is easy,” commented Bess.
Many of the original organizers plunged that first year and for many years after. “I love this event,” Nancy Newhouse commented, “I’ve plunged 10 or 11 times, and I’m going in this year at 80!” And Newhouse was among the first to attend in costume: “It’s fun to be silly! I’ve dressed up in a lot of different costumes. [The first year] I dressed up like a Butterball Turkey with bubble wrap, but it made me buoyant when I went in.” The event “brings everyone in the community together on a very special day,” she added. “A lot of people—year-round and seasonal—love the Weezie Library. Lucille & Bill Hayes donated the original funds for this children’s wing of the Atheneum:it’s named in honor of her sister.”
Louise Francis Walker, nicknamed “Weezie” by a younger sister who could not pronounce “Louise,” died tragically at just 10-years-old. In her memory, her parents started the Weezie Foundation dedicated to helping children. The Foundation gave half the cost of the children’s library, with a challenge to the Atheneum Board of Trustees to raise the other half.
Most of the original Plungers fondly remember Kendra Lockley’s homemade sticky buns served those early years. Island eateries donated warm beverages to give out at Children’s Beach (and still do that today). Plunge donation cards were printed on paper to be passed around to island businesses and residents.
One thing was clear from the start: “People really responded to the event,” said Leslie Malcolm, Atheneum executive director and head librarian. “I think that feeling was there after the very first event.” Now, twenty-five years later, the Plunge has grown into a beloved Thanksgiving tradition. Last year, about 1,100 people ran into the water. Paper pledge cards have been replaced by online fundraising for teams, and donors now come from well beyond the island. More Plungers than ever arrive in wacky and creative costumes. An MC has been added (Islanders Rocky Fox and Tom Bresette have both held that role) to give the countdown, reveal prize winners, and make other announcements. Tom Hanlon, from the original committee, still comes to the beach to help with set-up. For many years, Barbara and Ray Owen have brought one of their live turkeys to the event, an unofficial mascot (cover photo).
Prizes are awarded to notable Plungers every year in a variety of categories. So far the youngest Plunger was 3-years-old; the oldest was 87-year-old Ann Dwyer, whose twin sister served as her towel holder. (Every Cold Turkey Plunger needs a good wingman.)
Local artist G. S. Hill, has plunged every Thanksgiving since the very first year: initially alone, with his wife Judi Hill as his wingman. For the past 15 years Greg has plunged with dear friend Stacey Stuart, whose husband Peter Greenhalgh is her wingman. This team of four participates as Team Turkey Tini, and they have repeatedly raised $10,000 a year during this event for the Atheneum.
Hill says the cold water doesn’t much bother him, probably due to his custom of taking cold showers. He plunges “to support the Children’s Library: they do such a good job with the kids…and the money stays on-island.”
Stuart plunged on her own the first two years of the event, paused, and “when Judi told me Greg is doing it, I said ‘I’ll go in with him!’” Having grown up in Maine, the chilly water does not much bother Stacey: “I love the process of jumping in and jumping out. It has turned me into the kind of person who, wherever there is an ocean, I will jump in.”
Greg, Judi, Stacey, and Peter always arrive sporting distinctive hats that salute the holiday festivities. One year the hats were platters of turkeys. Now their signature hats are large martini glasses, sometimes with a garnish of turkeys or adirondack chairs. These hats are a nod, along with the team moniker, to their tradition of heading over to the White Elephant after the event for a toast.
All four members of Team Turkey Tini feel that the Cold Turkey Plunge is “a real feel-good part of Thanksgiving.” Stuart remembers her mother being an avid reader: “We always went to our home town library growing up; the Atheneum is now my home town library.”
Greg’s advice to first time plungers is “Dive all the way in and have fun!” Judi strongly suggests that wingmen be prepared to help Plungers put on something warm as soon as they emerge.
“Over the years, we have perfected our plunge,” Stacey explained. “I take my suit off immediately and put on my sweats before we go over to the White Elephant for an Irish coffee and martinis. We bring a cooler filled with dish towels, and we pour boiling water on the towels so they are warm…One year we went in and it was warmer in the water than out of the water, so I went in a second time. It turned out to be colder that second time, so I don’t do that any more.”
Another islander who has plunged all 25 years is Larry Manchester, who now plunges alongside his granddaughter Zoey, with his daughter Katie Manchester as wingman for them both, sometimes joined by brother Mark for the plunge. “It’s my good deed for the year,” said Larry.
Larry heard about the plunge when the Atheneum first held it when he was working at the electric company. “That first year it was 28 degrees! Scallopers couldn’t even go out [because of the cold temps]…it still takes my breath away,” he said. “It’s not bad once you get in there, but there are no prizes for staying in the water…I go in right near the pier so Sheila [the Harbormaster] can pull me out quick,” he added with a chuckle.
Zoey, Larry’s 11-year-old granddaughter, joined him a few years ago: “My papa was doing it so I decided to try it, and I liked it,” she explained. “Some of my friends do it, too.” Zoey likes the idea of helping the Atheneum, saying “I like to read.” Katie loves that her daughter plunges with her father: “I think it’s awesome! It’s her idea: she decided on her own to participate.”
Larry has a finely honed system for the morning of the Plunge: “I drive my truck down there with a big cooler filled with hot water, and ride my bike home. Then when I get out I stand in the hot water.”
Most years, the weather has cooperated. The exception was 2018, when a nor’easter and frigid water temperatures forced a postponement. After a 30-degree temperature swing, the Plunge was held the following day. Any final call on the weather belongs to the town and the harbormaster.
Plenty happens behind the scenes. Atheneum staff work with every department in town, with lifeguards in the water and fire, EMTs, and police on site for safety. “We get lots of great support and collaboration from the Town that day,” said the Atheneum team.
The Plunge has been at Children’s Beach since day one. “We intentionally keep the event consistent,” the Atheneum’s team explained. However, in 2020, when the pandemic kept everyone distanced, Atheneum staff brainstormed a virtual “Plunge Day Your Way,” asking participants to send videos of their plunges. “People got wonderfully creative.” Some islanders still plunged at Children’s Beach Thanksgiving morning, while others jumped into oceans in other beach towns. One woman in Beacon Hill had hera spouse dump a bucket of water on her from a couple of stories up. In Minnesota, plungers made snow angels in their swimsuits. A fun video collage of those who “plunged their way” can be watched at the Nantucket Atheneum’s YouTube page:
Some Plungers still participate remotely in this fundraiser, with all the heart and soul demonstrated by the in-person Plungers at Children’s Beach.
With the costumes, the camaraderie, and the excitement, the Atheneum’s Cold Turkey Plunge is a fun start to Thanksgiving Day. Behind the laughter is a serious purpose. “The Plunge provides a significant amount of the Weezie Library’s budget each year…This year’s goal is $150,000,” explained Maggie O’Reilly the Atheneum’s director of development. Over the quarter century the event has been held, it has raised more than $1.5 million. “Participating in the Plunge has an immediate effect on our ability to serve the community and on our ability to deliver our mission to Nantucket.”
O’Reilly believes the event has lasted because it connects to something deeper than most fundraisers. “It’s such a fun community event: it has become part of a tradition… it’s high energy and a fun way to start the holiday. People do it as a family. And it benefits a local institution, so it’s a cause that people feel good about.”
More than 1,000 plungers are expected again this year, along with some fun anniversary notes and memorabilia that will only be available at the event.
Participants can register in advance at nantucketatheneum.org for $35 per person, or on the morning of the event until 9:59 for $50. Anyone who’d rather skip the line the morning of may stop by the Nantucket Atheneum on Wednesday, November 25, between 10 am to 2 pm to pick up Plunge bracelets and their Tshirts (this is your best shot at getting your preferred T-shirt size).
Twenty-five years in, the Plunge is still what it was on day one: a few minutes of cold, a lot of noise, and a community that shows up for each other. As the Atheneum puts it, “We hope it continues for the next 25 years… maybe with even more generations taking part.”